Short answer: judge a design agency on how it will work with you, not only on what it has made for others. Before signing, look at the questions it asks you, how much its proposal explains beyond the design itself, whether its files are prepared for every medium you use, and what happens after delivery.

Alexis Presti, LostWoods’ founder, has more than ten years of design experience, in-house and in agency teams. He has taken over projects where the previous agency had been chosen for its portfolio and its client list, and brand files that needed work before they could be used. Here is what those projects taught him about choosing well.

What a portfolio cannot show you

A portfolio shows finished images, selected by the agency, in their best light. It does not show how the work was built, whether it still works a year later, or how the project went for the client.

The files Alexis has taken over tell the other side of the story. A logo that was not prepared for the web. A logo that was not cleanly built, which had to be cleaned up before its variations could be prepared. A logo designed only for screens, whose colours stopped working once the company needed print. Colours defined in RGB, the colour mode of screens, do not always survive the conversion to CMYK, the four inks used in printing: some can lose their intensity or cannot be reproduced at all.

In the cases Alexis describes, the graphic choices had been made without rules for future uses. No defined variations, no guidelines, nothing to tell the next person how to use the brand. That is why a brand identity should come with clear brand guidelines, not just a logo file.

Questions a good agency asks at the first meeting

The first meeting tells you more than the portfolio. A good agency asks before it proposes. These are the questions Alexis brings to a first meeting:

  • Where is your company today?
  • Where do you want it to be in a year?
  • In the best case, how would we work together on this project?
  • What happens after the project is delivered?

The answers shape the scope, the priorities and the deliverables. An agency that sends you a price without having asked anything about your business is quoting a deliverable. It is not yet working on your problem.

How to compare two design proposals

Two quotes for the same project can differ in price, but also in what they describe. Some list a deliverable and a price, full stop. Others describe the framing phase: the work done before any visual design, to understand the current situation, agree on how the project will run and plan every step.

That phase is not a formality. Alexis says it can take half of the project, sometimes nearly three quarters. It covers the current state of the brand, the direction, how you will work together, who gives direction, who approves, the schedule and the validation steps. For a website or a product interface, it also includes the site structure, the user journeys, the wireframes and the foundations of the design system. Only then does the visual design start.

« Once you stop being a designer who only executes and start thinking about the business, the work before design takes a huge amount of time: easily half the project, sometimes nearly three quarters. » Alexis Presti, Founder of LostWoods

A quote that leaves this phase out still leaves its questions open. They will have to be answered at some point, often in the middle of the project. Use this grid to compare proposals:

What to check A quote that only lists deliverables A detailed proposal
Framing Not mentioned Current state, objectives and method agreed before design
Decisions Not defined Who gives direction and who approves, on both sides
Schedule A delivery date Steps, validation points and revision rounds
Files « Logo + colours » Variations and formats for the media you use, on screen and in print
Rules None Brand guidelines your teams and partners can apply
After delivery Nothing What happens next, and who maintains the brand

Plan for languages, web and print from the start

Multilingual work comes up constantly in Luxembourg, where French, German, Luxembourgish and English often coexist, along with other languages depending on your audience. Alexis worked on a project designed in French and English, then asked to add German later. The German text broke many of the layouts, and the layout had to be reworked.

His advice: if you already know which languages you will need, design with the most demanding one first. In his experience, German is one of them. Ask the agency how it handles languages, and which media the files must work on, before the design starts, not after.

The same reflex applies to public tenders, a common route for public organisations in Luxembourg. The criteria depend on each call for tenders, but in the ones Alexis has answered, the evaluation also looked at the range of what the agency could deliver and how it works. Private companies can ask the same of every agency: explain your method, not just your visuals.

When a smaller project is enough

Not every need calls for a full framing phase. If your brand is already solid, with clear rules, a one-off flyer, an event visual or a single campaign can be handled quickly by an agency or a freelancer who simply applies those rules. The question then is whether your rules are clear enough for anyone to follow. We compared the options honestly in design agency, freelancer or in-house designer.

The detailed approach matters when you are creating or rebuilding something: a brand identity, a website, a product interface, or anything your teams will use for years.

Seven questions to ask before signing

  1. What do you need to know about our business before you send a quote?
  2. Who will work on our project, and who approves the work on our side?
  3. What happens before the design starts, and how long does it take?
  4. In which formats will we receive the files, for screen and for print?
  5. Will we get rules our teams can apply, or only files?
  6. How will you handle the languages we need?
  7. What happens after delivery?

You can also ask to see a project from start to finish, not only its final images. Each of our case studies starts from the client’s initial situation. If you want to go through these questions with us, start a conversation.

FAQ

Is a portfolio still useful when choosing a design agency?

Yes, to judge the style and the level of quality. It is not enough on its own: it shows results, not how the work was built or how the agency works with its clients. Combine it with the first meeting and a detailed proposal.

How much does a design agency cost in Luxembourg?

It depends on the scope. In Alexis’s experience, a focused but complete visual identity can start at around €5,000 excluding VAT. We explain how to build the full amount in our guide to planning a design budget in Luxembourg.

Can a new agency fix brand files made by a previous one?

Often, yes, if the original idea is worth keeping. A logo can be cleaned up, given its variations and its colour values for screen and print, then documented so your teams can use it. That is part of the work covered by our Brand Foundation.